Posted: Mar 10, 2019
| Year | Champion | Head Coach | Final | Site |
| 2023 | Swarthmore | Landry Kosmalski | d. Johns Hopkins, 76-73 | Johns Hopkins |
| 2022 | Johns Hopkins | Josh Loeffler | d. Swarthmore, 80-66 | Johns Hopkins |
| 2020 | Johns Hopkins | Josh Loeffler | d. Swarthmore, 73-71 | Swarthmore |
| 2019 | Swarthmore | Landry Kosmalski | d. Johns Hopkins, 79-61 | Swarthmore |
| 2018 | Johns Hopkins | Josh Loeffler | d. Swarthmore, 61-57 | Swarthmore |
| 2017 | Swarthmore | Landry Kosmalski | d. Dickinson, 68-64 | Swarthmore |
| 2016 | Franklin & Marshall | Glenn Robinson | d. Swarthmore, 75-64 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 2015 | Dickinson | Alan Seretti | d. Johns Hopkins, 65-62 | Johns Hopkins |
| 2014 | Johns Hopkins | Bill Nelson | d. Dickinson, 60-55 | Dickinson |
| 2013 | Dickinson | Alan Seretti | d. Franklin & Marshall, 64-40 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 2012 | Franklin & Marshall | Glenn Robinson | d. Muhlenberg, 71-55 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 2011 | Franklin & Marshall | Glenn Robinson | d. Dickinson, 65-55 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 2010 | Franklin & Marshall | Glenn Robinson | d. Gettysburg, 66-62 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 2009 | Gettysburg | George Petrie | d. Franklin & Marshall, 73-65 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 2008 | Ursinus | Kevin Small | d. Gettysburg, 85-78 | Ursinus |
| 2007 | Johns Hopkins | Bill Nelson | d. Haverford, 68-61 | Johns Hopkins |
| 2006 | Ursinus | Kevin Small | d. Johns Hopkins, 100-82 | Ursinus |
| 2005 | Ursinus | Kevin Small | d. Franklin & Marshall, 72-70 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 2004 | Franklin & Marshall | Glenn Robinson | d. Johns Hopkins, 69-58 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 2003 | Ursinus | Kevin Small | d. Franklin & Marshall, 96-88 (OT) | Ursinus |
| 2002 | Gettysburg | George Petrie | d. Franklin & Marshall, 50-47 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 2001 | Gettysburg | George Petrie | d. Muhlenberg, 68-59 | Muhlenberg |
| 2000 | Franklin & Marshall | Glenn Robinson | d. Johns Hopkins, 75-67 (OT) | Franklin & Marshall |
| 1999 | Johns Hopkins | Bill Nelson | d. Washington College, 78-52 | Washington College |
| 1998 | Muhlenberg | Dave Madeira | d. Johns Hopkins, 55-53 | Johns Hopkins |
| 1997 | Dickinson | Dave Frohman | d. Swarthmore, 90-59 | Swarthmore |
| 1996 | Franklin & Marshall | Glenn Robinson | d. Gettysburg, 79-63 | Franklin & Marshall |
| 1995 | Muhlenberg | Dave Madeira | d. Franklin & Marshall, 88-86 (OT) | Muhlenberg |
| 1994 | Franklin & Marshall | Glenn Robinson | d. Johns Hopkins, 63-61 | Franklin & Marshall |