| First Team | Class | Weight | Hometown/High School |
| Collin Wickramaratna, Ursinus | Fr. | 125 | Marlton, N.J. / Cherokee |
| Ricky Cavallo, Johns Hopkins ^ | Sr. | 133 | Greensburg, Pa. / Greensburg Central Catholic |
| Troy Stanich, Stevens * | Jr. | 141 | Roxbury, N.J. / Roxbury |
| Brett Kaliner, Stevens ! | So. | 149 | West Chester, Pa. / Bayard Rustin |
| Dylan Van Sickell, Stevens ! | Jr. | 157 | Little Silver, N.J. / Christian Brothers Academy |
| Dylan Schwartz, Muhlenberg | Jr. | 165 | Richboro, Pa. / Council Rock South |
| Jimmy Fratantoni, Muhlenberg | Sr. | 174 | Chester Springs, Pa. / Owen J. Roberts |
| Josh Glantzman, Merchant Marine ! | Jr. | 184 | Allenwood, N.J. / Wall Township |
| Gennaro Cerminara, Muhlenberg ! | Sr. | 197 | Hummelstown, Pa. / Hershey |
| Paul Triandafilou, Gettysburg * | Sr. | 285 | Derwood, Md. / Georgetown Prep |
| Honorable Mention | Class | Weight | Hometown/High School |
| Akhil Vega, Stevens | Fr. | 125 | Cupertino, Calif. / Cupertino |
| Joey Borai, Stevens ! | Sr. | 133 | Toms River, N.J. / Toms River East |
| Sean Thompson, Gettysburg | So. | 141 | Plainsboro, N.J. / West Windsor-Plainsboro South |
| Colin Devlin, Gettysburg | Jr. | 149 | Dresher, Pa. / Upper Dublin |
| Dominick Reyes, Johns Hopkins | So. | 157 | Cockeysville, Md. / Loyola |
| Shane Conners, Washington and Lee | Jr. | 165 | Mount Airy, Md. / South Carroll |
| Robert Gennat, Stevens | Fr. | 174 | Sparta, N.J. / Sparta |
| Isaac Morales, Johns Hopkins ! | Sr. | 184 | Gilbert, Ariz. / Highland |
| Kurtis Hahn, Merchant Marine | Jr. | 197 | Winfield, Mo. / Whitfield School |
| Blake Bunce, Merchant Marine # | Sr. | 285 | Trophy Club, Texas / Byron Nelson |
* 1st team All-Centennial 2017 & 2018
# Honorable Mention All-Centennial in 2017 & 2018
! 1st team All-Centennial in 2018
^ Honorable Mention All-Centennial in 2018
Wrestler of the Year – Troy Stanich, Stevens, Jr., 141
Rookie of the Year – Collin Wickramaratna, Ursinus, Fr., 125
Coach of the Year – Joe Favia, Stevens
Notes
- Champions at the Centennial Conference meet are named first-team All-Centennial, while runners-up receive honorable mention.
- Three Stevens wrestler have earned Wrestler of the Year honors - Brandon MacWhinnie (2007-08), Zach Wilhelm (2018), and Troy Stanich (2019). McDaniel is the only other team to win three Wrestler of the Year awards.
- Stanich and Triandafilou three-peated as first-team selections. They become the 19th & 20th wrestlers in Centennial history to earn three individual titles.
- Wickramaratna is the second Ursinus wrestler to win Rookie of the Year honors, joining Derek Arnold (2014 ROY at 149).
- Favia was selected Coach of the Year for the fifth consecutive season. He is a 2012 Centennial champion at 165.
- Ursinus leads the gold medal count in Conference history with 57 while McDaniel is second with 43. Muhlenberg is third with 42, followed by Stevens (35), Merchant Marine (30), Gettysburg (24), Johns Hopkins (24), Swarthmore (2), Washington and Lee (2) and New York University (1).
All-Sportsmanship Team
Sean Thompson, Gettysburg, So., 141, Plainsboro, N.J.
Dane Morgan, Johns Hopkins, Sr., 165, North Royalton, Ohio
Garrett Vandervalk, McDaniel, So., 174, Westminster, Md.
Kimo Dial, Merchant Marine, Sr., 133, Poway, Calif.
Brian Jamison, Muhlenberg, Jr., 149, Abington, Pa.
Joey Borai, Stevens, Sr., 133, Toms River, N.J.
Collin Wickramaratna, Ursinus, Fr., 125, Marlton, N.J.
Ethan Hartman, Washington and Lee, Sr., 125, River Edge, N.J.