1983-1989 | 1990-1999 | 2000-2011 | Key: Players of the Year
1983: WR-Chris Connelly, Dickinson, Sr.; WR-Rich Johnson, McDaniel, Sr.; TE-John Tucker, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; OL-Bob Merle, Swarthmore; OL-Sean Crowley, Swarthmore, Jr.; OL-John Ridinger, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; OL-Steve Sullivan, Ursinus, Jr.; OL-Chris Phelan, Gettysburg; QB-Mark Campbell, So., Johns Hopkins; RB-Ray Condren, Gettysburg, Jr.; RB-Mark Garcia, Ursinus, Sr.; PK-Jim Flynn, Gettysburg, So.; DL-Glen Faust, Gettysburg; DL-Jeff Seagraves, Swarthmore; DL-Jerry Canavan, Franklin & Marshall, Jr.; DL-Bill Reiner, Muhlenberg, Jr.; LB-Dom Lepone, Swarthmore, Jr.; LB-Doug Fulmer, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; LB-Ray Beneke, Muhlenberg; DB-Kevin Mei, Muhlenberg, So.; DB-Rick Conner, McDaniel, Sr.; DB-Mike Caterbone, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; DB-Mark Cavallero, Gettysburg; P-Tom Neumann, Muhlenberg, So.