Posted: Nov 14, 2017
JHU's Alex Lachman game-winning 43-yard FG vs. Thomas More, 2009
Champions
| Year | Champion | Head Coach |
| 2022 | Susquehanna | Tom Perkovich |
| 2021 | Muhlenberg | Nate Milne |
| Johns Hopkins | Greg Chimera | |
| 2019 | Muhlenberg | Nate Milne |
| 2018 | Johns Hopkins | Jim Margraff |
| Muhlenberg | Nate Milne | |
| 2017 | Franklin & Marshall | John Troxell |
| Johns Hopkins | Jim Margraff | |
| 2016 | Johns Hopkins | Jim Margraff |
| 2015 | Johns Hopkins | Jim Margraff |
| 2014 | Johns Hopkins | Jim Margraff |
| 2013 | Johns Hopkins | Jim Margraff |
| 2012 | Johns Hopkins | Jim Margraff |
| 2011 | Johns Hopkins | Jim Margraff |
| 2010 | Johns Hopkins | Jim Margraff |
| Muhlenberg | Mike Donnelly | |
| Ursinus | Peter Gallagher | |
| 2009 | Johns Hopkins | Jim Margraff |
| 2008 | Muhlenberg | Mike Donnelly |
| 2007 | Muhlenberg | Mike Donnelly |
| 2006 | Dickinson | Darwin Breaux |
| 2005 | Johns Hopkins | Jim Margraff |
| 2004 | Dickinson | Darwin Breaux |
| Franklin & Marshall | Shawn Halloran | |
| Johns Hopkins | Jim Margraff | |
| McDaniel | Tim Keating | |
| Muhlenberg | Mike Donnelly | |
| 2003 | Johns Hopkins | Jim Margraff |
| Muhlenberg | Mike Donnelly | |
| 2002 | Johns Hopkins | Jim Margraff |
| McDaniel | Tim Keating | |
| Muhlenberg | Mike Donnelly | |
| 2001 | McDaniel | Tim Keating |
| Muhlenberg | Mike Donnelly | |
| 2000 | McDaniel | Tim Keating |
| 1999 | McDaniel | Tim Keating |
| 1998 | McDaniel | Tim Keating |
| 1997 | McDaniel | Tim Keating |
| 1996 | Ursinus | Steve Gilbert |
| 1995 | Franklin & Marshall | Tom Gilburg |
| 1994 | Dickinson | Darwin Breaux |
| 1993 | Dickinson | Darwin Breaux |
| Franklin & Marshall | Tom Gilburg | |
| 1992 | Dickinson | Ed Sweeney |
| 1991 | Dickinson | Ed Sweeney |
| 1990 | Dickinson | Ed Sweeney |
| 1989 | Dickinson | Ed Sweeney |
| 1988 | Dickinson | Ed Sweeney |
| Franklin & Marshall | Tom Gilburg | |
| 1987 | Franklin & Marshall | Tom Gilburg |
| 1986 | Franklin & Marshall | Tom Gilburg |
| Muhlenberg | Ralph Kirchenheiter | |
| 1985 | Gettysburg | Barry Streeter |
| 1984 | Gettysburg | Barry Streeter |
| Swarthmore | Tom Lapinski | |
| 1983 | Gettysburg | Barry Streeter |
| Muhlenberg | Ralph Kirchenheiter | |
| Swarthmore | Tom Lapinski |