1983-1989 | 1990-1999 | 2000-2011 | Key: Players of the Year
2011: QB-Hewitt Tomlin, Sr., Johns Hopkins; RB-Joe Rollins, Soph., McDaniel; RB-Greg Tellish, Sr., Susquehanna; WR-Dan Wodicka, Soph., Johns Hopkins; WR-Sam Wernick, Sr., Johns Hopkins; TE-Matt Knouse, Sr., Susquehanna; OL-Ed Rodger, Sr., Johns Hopkins; OL-Armand Jenifer, Soph., Johns Hopkins; OL-Victor Jaramillo, Sr., Ursinus; OL-Mike Porembski, Sr., Muhlenberg; OL-Roland Massimino, Sr., Johns Hopkins; DL-Allen Petros, Sr., Moravian; DL-Kale Sweeney, Sr., Johns Hopkins; DL-Sean Whelan, Sr., Ursinus; DL-Tyler Brown, Sr., Johns Hopkins; DL-Sam Cox, Sr., McDaniel; LB-Greg Martell, Sr., Ursinus; LB-Pat McDonough, Sr., Muhlenberg; LB-Ryan Piatek, Sr., Johns Hopkins; LB-Trevor Terpening, Sr., Susquehanna; DB-Mike Milano, Sr., Johns Hopkins; DB-Chris Rountree, Jr., Ursinus; DB-Chris Hartzell, Sr., Muhlenberg; DB-Scott Sullivan, Sr., Dickinson; PK-Spencer Hotaling, Fr., Susquehanna; P-Jake Nichols, Sr., McDaniel; KR-Al Desiderio, Sr., Ursinus.
2010: QB-Hewitt Tomlin, Jr., Johns Hopkins; RB-Terrence Dandridge, So., Muhlenberg; RB-Jamel Mutunga, Sr., Gettysburg; WR-Sam Wernick, Jr., Johns Hopkins; WR-Mike Ritter, Jr., Susquehanna; TE-Mike Deutch, Sr., Franklin & Marshall; OL-Ed Rodger, Jr., Johns Hopkins; OL-Anthony Figueroa, Jr., Ursinus; OL-Dan Cancelliere, Sr., Moravian; OL-Mike Porembski, Jr., Muhlenberg; OL-Victor Jaramillo, Sr., Ursinus; DL-Kenny Cobb, Jr., Muhlenberg; DL-Sam Cox, Sr., McDaniel; DL-Devin Collins, Sr., Johns Hopkins; DL-Allen Petros, Sr., Moravian; LB-Pat McDonough, Sr., Muhlenberg; LB-Greg Martell, Jr., Ursinus; LB-Ryan Piatek, Jr., Johns Hopkins; LB-Sam Massaro, So., Franklin & Marshall; DB-Chris Hartzell, Jr., Muhlenberg; DB-Chris Rountree, So., Ursinus; DB-Mike Milano, Jr., Johns Hopkins; DB-Chris Kolb, Sr., McDaniel; P-Bobby Eppleman, Sr., Susquehanna; PK-Alex Lachman, Sr., Johns Hopkins; KR-Anthony DeSalva, Sr., Gettysburg.
2009: QB-Ian Mitchell, Dickinson, Sr.; RB-Andrew Kase, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; RB-Jamel Mutunga, Gettysburg, Jr.; WR-George Eager, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; WR-Phil Cresta, Muhlenberg, Sr.; TE-Mike Deutch, Franklin & Marshall, Jr.; OL-Clarke Miller, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; OL-Mike Stoffel, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; OL-Tim Miller, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; Anthony Abbate, Dickinson, Sr.; OL-Victor Jaramillo, Ursinus, Jr.; PK-Gordon Craig, Dickinson, Sr.; KR-George Eager, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; DL-Glenn Rocca, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; DL-Seth Payne, Moravian, So.; DL-Steve Levinson, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; DL-Frank Emmett, Muhlenberg, Sr.; LB-Colin Wixted, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; LB-Pat McDonough, Muhlenberg, Jr.; LB-Pete Hamill, Dickinson, Jr.; LB-Mike Weick, McDaniel, Sr.; DB-Barry Lovett, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; DB-Chris Rountree, Ursinus, Fr.; DB-Mike Maxwell, Dickinson, Sr.; DB-Mike Milano, Johns Hopkins, So.; P-Brian Betley, Gettysburg, Jr.
2008: QB-Eric Santagato, Muhlenberg, Sr.; RB-John DeLuca, Muhlenberg, Sr.; RB-Andrew Kase, Johns Hopkins, Jr.; WR-Pat O’Connor, Dickinson, Jr.; WR=Phil Cresta, Muhlenberg, Jr.; TE-Matt Jenschke, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; OL-Mike Nolan, Muhlenberg, Sr.; OL-Tim McBride, Moravian, Sr.; OL-Anthony Abbate, Dickinson, Jr.; OL-Mike Stoffel, Johns Hopkins, Jr.; OL-Steve Pavegkio, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; PK-Brian Reckenbeil, Moravian, Sr.; KR-George Eager, Franklin & Marshall, Jr.; DL-Billy Moates, Muhlenberg, Sr.; DL-Doug Bocchino, Moravian, Sr.; DL-Steve Bokron, Dickinson, Sr.; DL-Josh Jerrold, Gettysburg, Sr.; LB-Matt Rathbun, Muhlenberg, Sr.; LB-Andrew Morrissey, Moravian, Sr.; LB-James Gregory, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; LB-A.J. Albert, Johns Hopkins, So.; DB-Carl Robinson, Moravian, Sr.; DB-Michael Dalton, Dickinson, Sr.; DB-Cam Ahouse, Muhlenberg, Jr.; DB-Barry Lovett, Franklin & Marshall, Jr.; P-Greg Zara, Ursinus, Sr.
2007: QB-Marc Braxmeier, Moravian, Jr.; RB-Tom Sturges, Gettysburg, Sr.; RB-John DeLuca, Muhlenberg, Jr.; WR-Chris McInerney, Dickinson, Sr.; WR-Lance Tippett, Juniata, Sr.; TE-Matt Johnson, Muhlenberg, Sr.; OL-Eric Adams, Moravian, Sr.; OL-Mike Nolan, Muhlenberg, Jr.; OL-Erik Frain, Dickinson, Sr.; OL-James Russell, Gettysburg, Sr.; OL-Carmen Gentile, Ursinus, Sr.; OL-Jon Rinkus, Ursinus, Sr.; PK-Alex Lachman, Johns Hopkins, Fr.; KR-Ryan VanWright, Ursinus, Sr.; DL-Chris Musselman, Muhlenberg, Sr.; DL-Eric Hertrich, Dickinson, Sr.; DL-Mike Kimpel, Ursinus, Sr.; DL-Chris Swensen, Muhlenberg, Sr.; LB-Eric Dube, Dickinson, Sr.; LB-Dustin Good, Muhlenberg, Sr.; LB-Tom Tarsitano, Muhlenberg, Sr.; LB-Brian Hrynczyszyn, Ursinus, Sr.; DB-Brandon Doyle, Muhlenberg, Jr.; DB-Ryan VanWright, Ursinus, Sr.; DB-Richard Hill, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; DB-Dan Aitkens, Muhlenberg, So.; P-Tom Wenrich, McDaniel, Sr.
2006: QB-Matt Torchia, Dickinson, Sr.; RB-Tom Sturges, Gettysburg, Jr.; RB-Ryne Cantwell, Dickinson, Sr.; WR-Chris McInerney, Dickinson, Jr.; WR-Anthony Triplin, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; TE-Ryan Stearrett, Dickinson, Sr.; OL-Kevin Mentrikoski, Dickinson, Sr.; OL-Paul Markowski, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; OL-Brian Rice, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; OL-Jon Rinkus, Ursinus, Jr.; OL-Mike Nolan, Muhlenberg, So.; PK-Ben Scott, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; DL-Brian Cook, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; DL-Eric Hertrich, Dickinson, Jr.; DL-Chris Musselman, Muhlenberg, Sr.; DL-Mike Trio, Ursinus, Sr.; LB-Eric Dube, Dickinson, Jr.; LB-Matt Hagel, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; LB-Brian Hrynczyszyn, Ursinus, Jr.; LB-Harold Barton, Gettysburg, Sr.; DB-Drew Abbamonte, McDaniel, Sr.; DB-DeVohn Butler, Ursinus, So.; DB-Andrew Ackley, Dickinson, Sr.; DB-Chris Chauvin, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; P-Ben Scott, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; KR-Chris McInerney, Dickinson, Jr.
2005: QB-Vince Gallagher, Ursinus, Sr.; RB-T.J. Lyons, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; RB-Tom Sturges, Gettysburg, So.; WR-Anthony Triplin, Johns Hopkins, Jr.; WR-Kyle Douglass, Muhlenberg, Sr.; TE-Ryan Stearrett, Dickinson, Jr.; OL-Marc DeGennaro, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; OL-Kevin Mentrikoski, Dickinson, Jr.; OL-Brian Rice, Franklin & Marshall, Jr.; OL-Paul Markowski, Johns Hopkins, Jr.; OL-Carl Slabicki, Muhlenberg, Sr.; PK-Brandon Kline, Franklin & Marshall, Fr.; DL-Brian Cook, Johns Hopkins, Jr.; DL-Will Corbin, Muhlenberg, Sr.; DL-Chase Noll, McDaniel, Sr.; DL-Anthony Woodard, Johns Hopkins, Jr.; LB-Dan McCall, Muhlenberg, Sr.; LB-Adam Luke, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; LB-Ron Ringgold, McDaniel, Sr.; LB-Chris Stepien, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; DB-Andrew Ackley, Dickinson, Jr.; DB-Adam Colicchio, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; DB-Drew Abbamonte, McDaniel, Jr.; DB-Nathan Smith, Gettysburg, Sr.; DB-Adam Schmidt, Ursinus, Sr.; P-Ben Scott, Johns Hopkins, Jr.; KR-Nathan Smith, Gettysburg, Sr.
2004: QB-Jeff Harner, Franklin & Marshall, So.; RB-Broderick Maybank, McDaniel, Jr.; RB-Adam Cook, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; WR-Brian Wolcott, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; WR-Derek Boyce, Franklin & Marshall, Jr.; TE-Ryan Stearrett, Dickinson, So.; OL-Matt Weeks, Johns Hopkins, Sr., OL-Frank Santini, Muhlenberg, Sr.; OL-Brad Stewart, McDaniel, Sr.; OL-Robert Olson, Dickinson, Sr.; OL-Mike Leanch, Muhlenberg, Jr.; PK-Dan Eggertsson, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; DL-Mike Della Pella, Muhlenberg, Sr.; Dl-Bob Ziegler, Dickinson, Sr.; DL-Brett Rough, McDaniel, Jr.; DL-Dan McCall, Muhlenberg, Jr.; LB-Ryan Peer, Muhlenberg, Sr.; LB-Ron Ringgold, McDaniel, Jr.; LB-Dan Walker, Muhlenberg, Sr.; LB-Grant Acker, Gettysburg, Sr.; DB-Andrew Ackley, Dickinson, So.; DB-Justin Adair, Muhlenberg, Jr.; DB-Matt Campbell, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; DB-Andy Lee, McDaniel, Sr.; DB-Mike McCurley, Muhlenberg, Jr.; P-Dan Eggertsson, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; KR-Chris Martin, McDaniel, So.
2003: QB-George Merrell, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; RB-Adam Cook, Johns Hopkins, Jr.; RB-Matt Bernardo, Muhlenberg, Sr.; WR-Justin Salton, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; WR-Kodi Shay, Muhlenberg, Sr.; TE-Rob Sherman, Muhlenberg, Sr.; OL-Matt Weeks, Johns Hopkins, Jr.; OL-Chris Radomski, Muhlenberg, Sr.; OL-Frank Santini, Muhlenberg, Sr.; OL-Brad Stewart, McDaniel, Jr.; OL-Enoch Boateng, Gettysburg, So.; PK-Nate Getchell, McDaniel, Jr.; DL-Paul Smith, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; DL-Mike Della Pella, Muhlenberg, Jr.; DL-Dan McCall, Muhlenberg, So.; DL-Tony Braglio, McDaniel, Sr.; LB-Tony Briscella, Muhlenberg, Sr.; LB-Paul Longo, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; LB-Grant Acker, Gettysburg, Jr.; LB-Omar Philip, McDaniel, Sr.; DB-Matt Campbell, Johns Hopkins, Jr.; DB-Rob Wingfield, McDaniel, Sr.; DB-Thanasis Petrakis, Muhlenberg, Sr.; P-Corey Allen, McDaniel, So.; KR-Kodi Shay, Muhlenberg, Sr.
2002: QB-Justin Jones, Muhlenberg, Sr.; RB-Matt Bernardo, Muhlenberg, Jr.; RB-Gary Sheffield, Ursinus, Jr.; WR-Justin Salton, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; WR-Chris Glowacki, Ursinus, Sr.; TE-Rob Sherman, Muhlenberg, Jr.; OL-John Rydzewski, McDaniel, Sr.; OL-Leif Glynn, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; OL-Chris Radomski, Muhlenberg, Jr.; OL-Kevin Kostibos, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; OL-Robert Olson, Dickinson, So.; PK-Chris Reed, Muhlenberg, Sr.; DL-Chris Gallino, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; DL-Patrick Doyle, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; DL-Tyler Cathey, Muhlenberg, Sr.; DL-Jesse Hudson, McDaniel, Sr.; LB-Matt Wilchinski, McDaniel, Sr.; LB-Beau Sherry, Muhlenberg, Sr.; LB-Omar Philip, McDaniel, Jr.; LB-Mike Little, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; DB-Rob Wingfield, McDaniel, Jr.; DB-Matt Campbell, Johns Hopkins, So.; DB-Jay Tressler, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; P-Cody Peer, Dickinson, So.; KR-Kodi Shay, Muhlenberg, Jr.
2001: QB-Jamie Harris, McDaniel, Sr.; RB-Matt Bernardo, Muhlenberg, So.; RB-Shearrod Duncan, Ursinus, Sr.; WR-Joshua Carter, Muhlenberg, Sr.; WR-Teron Powell, McDaniel, Sr.; WR-Zach Baylin, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; TE-Mike Stankowitz, Muhlenberg, Sr.; OL-Nick Alevrogiannis, McDaniel, Jr.; OL-Kevin Kostibos, Johns Hopkins, Jr.; OL-Joe Muccia, Muhlenberg, Sr.; OL-Scott Blum, Dickinson, Fr.; OL-Brian McArdle, Ursinus, Jr.; PK-Marr Andrade, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; DL-Erich Hellmold, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; DL-Paul Schmidt, Ursinus, Sr.; DL-Keith Fischer, Dickinson, Sr.; DL-Josh Galemore, McDaniel, Sr.; LB-Beau Sherry, Muhlenberg, Jr.; LB-Matt Wilchinski, McDaniel, Jr.; LB-Ryan Moore, Gettysburg, Sr.; LB-Athan Margetas, McDaniel, Sr.; DB-Jason Wingeart, McDaniel, Sr.; DB-Mike Dale, Ursinus, Sr.; DB-Mike Jackowski, Dickinson, Jr.; DB-Erik Hammar, Muhlenberg, Sr.; P-Mark Rowand, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; KR-Joshua Carter, Muhlenberg, Sr.
2000: QB-Jamie Harris, McDaniel, Jr.; RB-Ken Clark, Swarthmore, So.; RB-Scott Martorana, Johns Hopkins, Sr.; WR-Zach Baylin, Johns Hopkins, Jr.; WR-Joshua Carter, Muhlenberg, Jr.; WR-Rashard Williams, Ursinus, Sr.; TE-Andy Gilburg, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; OL-John Schoeller, Muhlenberg, Sr.; OL-John Rydzewski, McDaniel, So.; OL-Mat Rapoza, Swarthmore, So.; OL-Brian McArdle, Ursinus, So.; OL-Mike Kochler, Ursinus, Sr.; PK-Brent Sandrock, McDaniel, Sr.; DL-Aaron Bartolain, McDaniel, Sr.; DL-David Jones, Muhlenberg, Sr.; DL-Keith Fischer, Dickinson, Jr.; DL-Paul Graham, Ursinus, Jr.; LB-Matt Wilchinski, McDaniel, So.; LB-Doug Folger, Muhlenberg, Jr.; LB-Chuck Nesley, Dickinson, So.; LB-Joe Conte, Ursinus, Sr.; DB-Rob McCracken, McDaniel, Sr.; DB-Eric Cowie, Ursinus, Jr.; DB-Mike Burke, Muhlenberg, Sr.; DB-Jason Wingeart, McDaniel, Jr.; P-Andy Gilburg, Franklin & Marshall, Sr.; KR-Joshua Carter, Muhlenberg, Jr.