Luke Schuerman, Johns Hopkins, So., DE (AP-1, D3-1)

Michael Feaster, Muhlenberg, Sr., WR (D3-2)

JR Woods, Johns Hopkins, Jr., T (AP-1, D3-2)

Michael Hnatkowsky, Muhlenberg, Sr., QB (AFCA-2, D3-3)

Michael Lefever, Susquehanna, Sr., TE (D3-3)

Spencer Kirin, Muhlenberg, Sr., LB (D3-3)

James McGettigan, Muhlenberg, Sr., LS (D3-3)

Macauley Kilbane, Johns Hopkins, Sr., S (D3-4)

Frankie Feaster, Muhlenberg, Sr., DL (AFCA-1, AP-1, D3-1) 

Danial Shelton, Susquehanna, Sr., DB (AFCA-1, D3-1, AP-2)

Ryan Curtiss, Muhlenberg, Sr., TE (AP-1, AFCA-2, D3-3) 

Ryan Malarkey, Muhlenberg, Sr., OT (AP-2, D3-3) 

Ryan Curtiss, Muhlenberg, Jr., TE (AFCA-1) read more

Danial Shelton, Susquehanna, Jr., DB (AFCA-2) read more

Jack Toner, Johns Hopkins, Sr., S (AFCA-1, D3-3) read more

Chantz Anderson, Johns Hopkins, Sr., C (D3-3) read more

Nick Lamb, Muhlenberg, Sr., KR, (D3-3) read more

Colin Egan, Johns Hopkins, Jr., OT (D3-1) read more

Michael Long, Muhlenberg, Sr., TE (D3-1) read more 

Armand Jenifer, Johns Hopkins, Sr., OT (AP-1, AFCA-1, D3-2) read more

Ben Cranston, Johns Hopkins, Sr., C (D3-1) read more

2011

Pat McDonough, Muhlenberg, Sr., LB (AFCA-1, AP-2, D3-3) read more

Allen Petros, Moravian, Sr., DE (D3-3) read more

2010

Pat McDonough, Muhlenberg, Sr., LB (D3-2) read more

2009

Andrew Kase, Johns Hopkins, Sr., RB (D3-3) read more

2008

John DeLuca, Muhlenberg, Sr., RB (D3-3) read more
Matt Rathbun, Muhlenberg, Sr., LB (D3-3) read more

2007

Tom Sturges, Gettysburg, Sr., RB (AFCA-1) read more
Eric Dube, Dickinson, Sr., LB (D3-3)
Alex Lachman, Johns Hopkins, Fr., PK (D3-3) read more
Matt Johnson, Muhlenberg, Sr., TE (D3-3) read more

2006

Ben Scott, Johns Hopkins, Sr., P (AFCA-1, FBG-1, D3-2), PK (D3-3) read more
Drew Abbamonte, McDaniel, Sr., DB (FBG-2) read more
Eric Dube, Dickinson, Jr., LB (D3-3)

2005

Dan McCall, Muhlenberg, Sr., LB (FBG-1, D3-3) read more
Ron Ringgold, McDaniel, Sr., LB (FBG-3)

2004

Dan Eggertsson, Frank. & Marshall, Sr., P (AFCA-1, D3-2, FBG-3) read more

2003

Matt Campbell, Johns Hopkins, Jr., DB (SID-1, AP-2, D3-3) read more
Kodi Shay, Muhlenberg, Sr., WR (SID-1) read more
Matt Campbell, Johns Hopkins, Jr., S (D3-3)
Matt Weeks, Johns Hopkins, Jr., OL (FBG-3) read more
Chris Radomski, Muhlenberg, Sr., OT (D3-3)

2002

Chris Reed, Muhlenberg, Sr., PK (AFCA-1, SID-1, FBG-1) read more
Matt Wilchinski, McDaniel, Sr., LB (D3-3)

2001

Shearrod Duncan, Ursinus, Sr., RB (SID-1, FBG-1, D3-2)
Jason Wingeart, McDaniel, Sr., DB (AFCA-1, SID-1, D3-2)
Ryan Moore, Gettysburg, Sr., LB (D3-1)
Joshua Carter, Muhlenberg, Sr., WR/KR (SID-3) read more
Mike Dale, Ursinus, Sr., DB (SID-3)

2000

Joshua Carter, Muhlenberg, Jr., KR (SID-1, D3-1, FBG-2) read more
Eric Cowie, Ursinus, Sr., DB (SID-1, FBG-1, D3-2)
Mike Burke, Muhlenberg, Sr., DB (FBG-2, SID-3) read more
Mat Rapoza, Swarthmore, So., OL (D3-2)
John Schoeller, Muhlenberg, Sr., OL (FBG-3) read more
Jason Wingeart, McDaniel, Jr., DB (SID-3)

1999

Keith Fischer, Dickinson, DL (D3-1)
Paul Smith, Gettysburg, Sr., RB (D3-1), KR (AFCA-1)
Tom Selecky, McDaniel, Sr., LB (SID-1)
Marvin Deal, McDaniel, Sr., DB (D3-1; SID-2; FBG-3)
Joshua Carter, Muhlenberg, So., KR (SID-1, FBG-1, D3-1)
Terry Kohler, Dickinson, Sr., OL (D3-3)

1998

Mat Mathias, McDaniel, Sr., OT (AFCA-1; SID-3)
Jason Shoff, Dickinson, Sr., DL (AFCA-1, SID-2)
Paul Smith, Gettysburg, Sr., KR (AFCA-1; SID-2)
Tom Selecky, McDaniel, Jr., LB (SID-2)
Harrison Bernstein, Johns Hopkins, Jr., DB (SID-2)
Ryan Hines, McDaniel, Sr., OG (SID-3)
Tom Lapato, McDaniel, Sr., DB (SID-3)

1997

Tom Selecky, McDaniel, So., LB (SID-2)
Paul Smith, Gettysburg, So., FB (SID-3)
Harrison Bernstein, Johns Hopkins, So., (SID-3)
Marvin Deal, McDaniel, So., KR (SID-3)

1996

Peter Hinckle, Ursinus, So., DB (SID-1, AP-1)
Jim Wilson, Johns Hopkins, Sr., DL (SID-2)
Todd Bencivenni, Johns Hopkins, Jr., PK (SID-2)
Matt Bixler, Dickinson, Sr., LB (SID-3)
Charles Warren, Dickinson, Sr., DB (SID-3)

1995

Matt Bixler, Dickinson, Jr., LB (SID-2)
Vince Harper, Franklin & Marshall, Jr., DB (SID-2)

1994

Jason Fox, Dickinson, Sr., LB (AFCA-1, SID-2)
Dwayne Marcus, Gettysburg, Sr., FB (SID-1)
Brian Campbell, Dickinson, Sr., OL (SID-2)
Chris Notarfrancesco, Gettysburg, Sr., WR (SID-2)
Steve Cohen, Dickinson, Sr., OL (SID-3)
Charles Warren, Dickinson, So., DB (SID-3)

1993

Rob Lokerson, Muhlenberg, Jr., WR (SID-1, AFCA-1)
Stu Markley, Johns Hopkins, Sr., LB (SID-3)
Jelani Rucker, Johns Hopkins, Jr., DL (SID-3)
Bill Sedgwick, Ursinus, Sr., RB (SID-3)

1992

Brian Ridgway, Dickinson, Sr., DE (SID-1)
Dwayne Marcus, Gettysburg, So., FB (SID-2)
Chip Chevalier, Swarthmore, Sr., QB (SID-3)
Josh Drake, Swarthmore, Jr., WR (SID-3)
Jim McGeehan, Dickinson, Sr., DE (SID-3)

1991

Shaughn White, Dickinson, Sr., DB (SID-1)
Eric Frees, McDaniel, Sr., RB (SID-3)
Alberto Mascaro, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., DE (SID-3)

1990

Eric Frees, McDaniel, Jr., RB (SID-2)

1989

Dale Amos, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., WR (SID-1, AFCA-1)
Marshall Happer, Swarthmore, Sr., OL (AFCA-1)
Larry Barone, Dickinson, Sr., DT (SID-2)
Mike Birosak, Dickinson, Sr., RB (SID-2)
Alberto Mascaro, Franklin & Marshall, So., DE (SID-2)
Mike Quinn, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., C (SID-2)

1988

Dale Amos, Franklin & Marshall, Jr., WR (SID-1)
Andy Zuch, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., DB (SID-1)
Jack Savage, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., DT (SID-3)

1987

John Rogers, Franklin & Marshall, Jr., DB (SID-1)
Dale Amos, Franklin & Marshall, So., WR (SID-2)
Dave Pfund, Muhlenberg, Sr., OT (SID-2)
Joe Procida, Franklin & Marshall, Sr., LB (SID-2)
Jack Savage, Franklin & Marshall, Jr., DT (SID-2)

1985

Paul Martin, Gettysburg, Sr., FB (SID-1)
Brian Barr, Gettysburg, Sr., DB (AFCA-1)

1984

Ray Condren, Gettysburg, Sr., FB (SID-1, AFCA-1, AP-1)
Dom Lepone, Swarthmore, Sr., LB (SID-1)
Eddie Greene, Swarthmore, Sr., DB (SID-2)
Sean Crowley, Swarthmore, Sr., OT (SID-3)
Miguel Yanes, Gettysburg, Jr., LB (SID-3)

1983

Ray Condren, Gettysburg, Jr., FB (SID-1, AFCA-1)