Centennial Conference Men's Lacrosse USILA First-Team All-Americans
Casey McNight Washington College |
Matt Cherry Dickinson |
Andrew McGann Gettysburg |
Steve Berger Washington |
Brandon Palladino Dickinson |
| Year | Name, School, Class, Position |
| 1994 | Jason Paige, Washington College, Jr., A |
| Brett Smith, Gettysburg, Sr., M | |
| 1995 | Dave Curry, Gettysburg, Sr., M |
| Brian McGurn, Gettysburg, Sr., D | |
| 1996 | George Atterbury, Washington College, Jr., M |
| Bart Jaeger, Washington College, Sr., A | |
| 1997 | John Fuller, Washington College, So., A |
| George Atterbury, Washington College, Sr., M | |
| Andy Taibl, Washington College, Jr., G | |
| 1999 | Lee Hemming, Gettysburg, Sr., M |
| Brian Abbott, Gettysburg, Sr., D | |
| Andrew Barter, Gettysburg, Jr., G | |
| 2000 | J.D. Radebaugh, Washington College, Sr., M |
| 2001 | Pete Milliman, Gettysburg, Jr., A |
| Tommy Pearce, Gettysburg, Sr., M | |
| Mike Plantholt, Gettysburg, Sr., D | |
| 2002 | Jon Fellows, Washington College, Sr., A |
| Tim McGinnis, Gettysburg, Jr., G | |
| 2003 | Steve Berger, Washington College, Jr., M |
| 2004 | Steve Berger, Washington College, Sr., M |
| Kyle Mitten, Washington College, Jr., D | |
| 2006 | Pat Vaughan, Gettysburg, Jr., GK |
| 2007 | Andrew McGann, Gettysburg, Jr., D |
| Pat Vaughan, Gettysburg, Jr., GK | |
| 2008 | Andrew McGann, Gettysburg, Sr., D |
| 2009 | Tommy Kehoe, Gettysburg, Sr., LSM |
| Gordon Cohen, Washington College, Sr., GK | |
| 2010 | Kyle McGrath, Gettysburg, Sr., M |
| Tim Kurpis, Gettysburg, Sr., D | |
| 2012 | Brandon Palladino, Dickinson, Jr., LSM |
| 2013 | Brian Cannon, Dickinson, Jr., A |
| Matt Cherry, Dickinson, Sr., M | |
| Brandon Palladino, Dickinson, Sr., LSM | |
| Peter Zouck, Dickinson, Sr., D | |
| 2014 | Hunter Nowicki, Washington College, Sr., M |
| Casey McKnight, Washington College, Sr., D | |
| 2016 | Geoff Davis, Gettysburg, Sr., D |
| Jameson Smith, Gettysburg, Sr., M | |
| 2019 | Nate Usick, Dickinson, Sr., M |
| 2021 | Luke Keating, F&M, Sr., A |