Posted: May 30, 2019
Ursinus junior outfielder Alex Mumme and Johns Hopkins senior pitcher Jack Bunting were named to the America Baseball Coaches Association (ABCA) / Rawlings All-America Team, announced Thursday. Both Mumme and Bunting collected second team accolades.
| 2019 ABCA/Rawlings NCAA Div. III All-America Teams | ||||
| All-America First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Player | Cl. | School | State |
| C | Casey Combs | Sr. | East Texas Baptist | TX |
| 1B | Tim Johnson | So. | Sul Ross State | TX |
| 2B | Harry Witwer-Dukes | Jr. | Wooster | OH |
| 3B | Cal Aldridge | Sr. | Wisconsin-Whitewater | WI |
| SS | Nate Sides | Sr. | Alvernia | PA |
| OF | Bret Williams | Jr. | Penn State Harrisburg | PA |
| OF | Nick Herzog | Sr. | UMass Boston | MA |
| OF | Josh Goulet | Sr. | Plymouth State | NH |
| DH | Jeremy Jess | Jr. | Pomona Pitzer | CA |
| UT | John Brinkman | Jr. | Washington St. Louis | MO |
| P | Luke Summers | Jr. | Fontbonne | MO |
| P | John Howard | Sr. | Washington St. Louis | MO |
| P | Tyler Peck | Sr. | Chapman | CA |
| P | Nick Roth | Sr. | Randolph-Macon | VA |
| RP | Nick Garcia | So. | Chapman | CA |
| All-America Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Player | Cl. | School | State |
| C | Alex Kachler | Jr. | Methodist | NC |
| C | Rob Marinec | So. | North Central | IL |
| 1B | Will Krushena | Jr. | Denison | OH |
| 2B | Bryce Rheault | Jr. | Buena Vista | IA |
| 2B | Miguel Torres | Sr. | Penn State Harrisburg | PA |
| 3B | Clayton Noakes | So. | Louisiana College | LA |
| SS | Nick DiNapoli | Sr. | Christopher Newport | VA |
| SS | Thomas Miller | So. | Adrian | MI |
| OF | Matt Woods | Sr. | Rowan | NJ |
| OF | Thomas Craig | Sr. | UT Dallas | TX |
| OF | Connor Brandon | Sr. | Concordia Chicago | IL |
| OF | Alex Mumme | Jr. | Ursinus | PA |
| DH | Dan Harwood | Jr. | Wooster | OH |
| UT | Christopher Peres | Sr. | La Verne | CA |
| P | Ben Lambert | Jr. | Southern Maine | ME |
| P | Danny Cody | Sr. | Baldwin Wallace | OH |
| P | Nolan McCarthy | Jr. | Occidental | CA |
| P | Jack Bunting | Sr. | Johns Hopkins | MD |
| RP | Bobby Tramondozzi | Sr. | UMass Boston | MA |
| RP | Gage Smart | Jr. | Buena Vista | IA |
| All-America Third Team | ||||
| Pos. | Player | Cl. | School | State |
| C | Graham Low | Sr. | Macalester | MN |
| 1B | Allen Murphy | Jr. | St. John Fisher | NY |
| 2B | Mullen Socha | Sr. | Washington & Jefferson | PA |
| 3B | Ben Swords | So. | Webster | MO |
| SS | Ben Boran | Sr. | Bethany Lutheran | MN |
| OF | Pat Keohane | Sr. | John Carroll | OH |
| OF | Noah Payne | Sr. | Howard Payne | TX |
| OF | Matt Psychas | Sr. | Heidelberg | OH |
| OF | Nick Fowkes | Sr. | Thiel | PA |
| P | Matt Valin | Sr. | Cortland | NY |
| P | James Green | So. | St. Mary's | MN |
| P | Matt Mulhearn | Jr. | Webster | MO |
| P | Ian McCole | So. | Misericordia | PA |
| P | RJ Hall | Sr. | Tufts | MA |
| P | Phil Mary | Sr. | Mount Union | OH |