Posted: Mar 10, 2019
Dan Twito of Merchant Marine celebrates his 157-pound national championship in 2011
Champions
| Year | Team Champion (Score) | Head Coach | Outstanding Wrestler (Weight Class) | Site |
| 2023 | Ursinus (84) | Joe Jamison | Luke Kowalski, Gettysburg (133) | Ursinus |
| 2022 | Washington and Lee (97) | Nathan Shearer | Eric Mougalian, Gettysburg (149) | Johns Hopkins |
| 2020 | Washington and Lee (75.5) | Nathan Shearer | Ryker Eckenbarger, McDaniel (141) | Muhlenberg |
| 2019 | Stevens (83) | Joe Favia | Ricky Cavallo, Johns Hopkins (133) | Merchant Marine |
| 2018 | Stevens (100) | Joe Favia | Zach Wilhelm, Stevens (157) | Washington and Lee |
| 2017 | Stevens (97.5) | Joe Favia | Troy Stanich, Stevens (133) | Stevens |
| 2016 | Stevens (121) | Joe Favia | Jared Forman, Johns Hopkins (174) | McDaniel |
| 2015 | Stevens (102.5) | Joe Favia | Mike Polizzi, Stevens (157) | McDaniel |
| 2014 | Ursinus (102.5) | Bill Racich | Mike Mui, Merchant Marine (125) | Ursinus |
| 2013 | Ursinus (113) | Bill Racich | Brandon Jones, NYU (133) | Johns Hopkins |
| 2012 | Johns Hopkins (79) | Keith Norris | Joe Favia, Stevens (165) | Gettysburg |
| 2011 | Merchant Marine (115) | Greg Ilaria | Judd Connell, Merchant Marine (285) | Washington and Lee |
| 2010 | Merchant Marine (88) | Greg Ilaria | Brock Glotfelty, McDaniel (285) | Stevens |
| 2009 | Merchant Marine (116) | Greg Ilaria | Andrew Goldstein, Gettysburg (157) | McDaniel |
| 2008 | Merchant Marine (99.5) | Tim Alger | Brandon MacWhinnie, Stevens (174) | Ursinus |
| 2007 | Ursinus (85.5) | Bill Racich | Brandon MacWhinnie, Stevens (165) | Gettysburg |
| 2006 | Ursinus (98.5) | Bill Racich | Tony Howard, McDaniel (165) | Johns Hopkins |
| 2005 | Ursinus (89) | Bill Racich | Eddie Murray, Ursinus (125) | Muhlenberg |
| 2004 | Ursinus (109) | Bill Racich | Scott Roesch, Ursinus (157) | Washington and Lee |
| 2003 | Ursinus (107) | Bill Racich | Mike Troutman, Ursinus (174) | McDaniel |
| 2002 | McDaniel (106.5) | John Lowe | Sean Howard, Ursinus (157) | Ursinus |
| 2001 | McDaniel (84) | John Lowe | Nate Yeasted, Muhlenberg (133) | Gettysburg |
| 2000 | McDaniel (102.5) | John Lowe | Charlie Conaway, McDaniel (184) | Johns Hopkins |
| 1999 | Ursinus (115.5) | Bill Racich | Josh Moyer, Ursinus (133) | Muhlenberg |
| 1998 | McDaniel (104) | John Lowe | Josh Moyer, Ursinus (134) | Swarthmore |
| 1997 | Ursinus (103) | Bill Racich | Craig Farris, Muhlenberg (150) | McDaniel |
| 1996 | Ursinus (86) | Bill Racich | Ted Speers, McDaniel (275) | Ursinus |
| 1995 | Muhlenberg (83) | Jim Carls | Jake Drell, Gettysburg (158) | Gettysburg |
| 1994 | Ursinus (82.5) | Bill Racich | Eric Williams, Swarthmore (158) | Ursinus |